Strengthen Your Investigation Skills

As an HR professional or internal investigator, you understand the importance of conducting fair and thorough investigations. But do you have the right tools and strategies to navigate complex cases with confidence?

I’ve been working on something to help you refine your skills and ensure your investigations are consistent, efficient, and effective. Get ready to take your investigative skills to the next level.

In the meantime, if you haven’t already, download my free tool to help streamline your investigations, and stay tuned for more details on what’s coming next!

Restoring Team Trust Post-Investigation

Workplace investigations, by their nature, can be disruptive and unsettling for everyone involved. Whether the investigation was about misconduct, harassment, or any other serious issue, the aftermath often leaves a team feeling fractured, mistrustful, and uncertain about the future. However, one of the most important and often overlooked aspects of the process is restoring team trust and cohesion post-investigation.

In my experience as a workplace investigator, I’ve often found that my job traditionally stops when I report out on my findings. However, many of my clients seek recommendations for how to move forward, especially when it comes to restoring team trust. Over the years, I’ve been a strong advocate for the importance of restoring the workplace after an investigation. Recognizing the need for specialized skills in this area, I recently completed training in workplace restoration to enhance my ability to offer valuable recommendations. This additional knowledge allows me to assist clients in rebuilding team trust and ensuring a healthier work environment, even when I am not serving as the investigator.

In today’s Investigative Edge, I want to share strategies for rebuilding trust and fostering a positive work environment after an investigation has been completed.

Understanding the Impact of an Investigation

Before diving into the strategies for restoring trust, it’s important to understand the potential impact an investigation can have on a team. The investigation process can stir up emotions such as fear, anger, and resentment. Common effects that can arise include:

1. Disruption of Team Dynamics: The investigation can create divisions within the team, as employees may take sides or feel isolated. This disruption can lead to a breakdown in collaboration and communication, making it difficult for the team to function effectively.

2. Erosion of Trust: Trust is often the first thing to go during an investigation. In the aftermath, employees’ trust in colleagues, management, or the organization is often broken. This erosion of trust can show up as increased skepticism and reluctance to engage fully in work.

3. Increased Anxiety and Uncertainty: Investigations often create a climate of fear and uncertainty, especially if employees are unsure about the outcomes or potential repercussions. This anxiety can lead to decreased productivity, as employees focus more on the investigation than on their work.

4. Damage to Morale and Engagement: The emotional toll of an investigation can significantly impact employee morale. Employees may feel distracted or unmotivated, leading to lower engagement and a decline in overall workplace satisfaction.

5. Spread of Rumors and Speculation: In the absence of clear communication, rumors and speculation can spread quickly, further escalating the situation. This can lead to misinformation and increased tension among team members who were not directly involved in the investigation but are still affected by the fallout.

Understanding these impacts is the first step toward effectively addressing them. With this awareness in mind, let’s explore strategies that can help rebuild trust and restore a positive work environment post-investigation.

Strategies for Restoring Trust

1. Communicate the Outcome Transparently (While Respecting Privacy): After an investigation is over, consider communicating the outcome to the team in a way that is both transparent and respectful of privacy. While specific details shouldn’t be disclosed, it’s important to reassure the team that the investigation was conducted thoroughly, fairly, and according to the organization’s policies. Emphasize the steps the organization has taken or will take to address the issues uncovered in the investigation. This communication helps to rebuild trust by showing that the organization is committed to accountability and fairness.

2. Acknowledge the Emotional Toll: It’s important to recognize and validate the emotional impact the investigation may have had on the team. Acknowledging these feelings shows empathy and helps to rebuild trust. Consider holding a team meeting or one-on-one discussions where employees can express their concerns and emotions. Providing a space for open dialogue can help to clear the air and reduce lingering issues.

3. Offer Support and Resources: After an investigation, employees may benefit from additional support to help them process the experience and move forward. Consider offering resources such as employee assistance programs, counseling services, conflict resolution workshops, or team-building activities. Providing access to these resources demonstrates that the organization cares about the well-being of its employees and is invested in helping them move forward and rebuild.

4. Focus on Rebuilding Relationships: One of the most significant challenges post-investigation is repairing relationships that may have been strained or broken during the process. Encourage team members to engage in open, honest communication with one another and provide opportunities for team-building exercises or facilitated discussions. These efforts can help rebuild connections and restore team dynamics.

5. Set Clear Expectations for the Future: To prevent future issues and build a more cohesive team, it’s important to set clear expectations for behavior and communication moving forward. This may involve revisiting the organization’s code of conduct, offering refresher training on workplace policies, or implementing team or departmental norms to promote a healthy and inclusive work environment. Clear expectations help to establish a new sense of direction, which can be help in rebuilding trust.

6. Monitor the Team’s Progress: Restoring trust is an ongoing process. Regularly check in with the team to gauge their feelings and address any ongoing concerns. Be on the lookout for signs of unresolved conflict and be proactive in addressing them. Continuous monitoring and support will help ensure that the team continues to move forward in a positive direction.

Conclusion

Restoring team trust after an investigation can be a delicate but necessary task. It requires clear communication, empathy, and a commitment to rebuilding relationships and reinforcing positive team dynamics. By taking the steps outlined above, you can help your employees move past the challenges of an investigation. Remember, the goal is not just to return to the status quo but to create a healthier and more supportive workplace.

If you liked this article, do me a favor and share it with a colleague or repost it to your network.

Together we’re building a community of investigators committed to elevating workplace culture.