Did you know? 42% of organizations have not adopted required investigation practices.

—HR Acuity Eighth Annual Employee Relations Benchmark Study

This means many HR professionals are still winging it when it comes to investigations. If you’re aiming for consistent, efficient, and effective investigations, it all starts with a solid plan. Our Workplace Investigation Planning Template is your roadmap to staying organized, following best practices, and ensuring every investigation is thorough.

Download your free template here.

Conducting interviews in sensitive cases—whether involving harassment, discrimination, or trauma—demands a careful and nuanced approach. The stakes are high: how you handle these interviews can affect the outcome of the investigation, the well-being of the interviewees, and the overall credibility of the process. It’s not just about asking the right questions; it’s about understanding the emotional and psychological dynamics at play, and approaching each interview with empathy, respect, and a well-thought-out strategy.

In today’s Investigative Edge, we’re diving into interview techniques for sensitive cases, exploring practical tips, and offering strategies to help you navigate these challenging conversations with care.

Understanding the Emotional Landscape

Sensitive cases often involve individuals who have experienced emotional or psychological distress. As an investigator, it’s important to recognize the emotional context before you begin the interview. This awareness will help you to understand the potential trauma or anxiety an interviewee might be experiencing.

Pre-Interview Assessment
Before the interview, take time to conduct a pre-interview assessment. This involves gathering as much context as possible about the interviewee’s state of mind. Review previous interactions, understand workplace dynamics, and consult with HR professionals or managers who have engaged with the individual. A pre-interview assessment allows you to tailor your approach, ensuring you’re prepared for any emotional reactions or reluctance to share.

Building Rapport

Building rapport is essential in any interview, but it becomes even more important in sensitive cases. The interviewee needs to feel safe and understood to open up about potentially painful experiences. However, building rapport in these situations isn’t about being friendly, it’s about demonstrating genuine empathy and understanding.

Start with Grounding Conversations
Begin the interview with a conversation that grounds the interviewee in the present moment. Ask how they’re feeling today or if they have any concerns before starting. This approach not only builds rapport but also gives you insight into their current emotional state.

Reflective Listening
Use reflective listening to show that you’re actively listening and to encourage the interviewee to elaborate. For example, if they say, “I felt very isolated after the incident,” you might respond, “It sounds like that experience left you feeling quite alone.” This technique fosters a deeper connection and encourages the interviewee to share more.

Questioning Techniques to Navigate the Nuances

The way you frame your questions can significantly influence the quality of the information you gather, especially in sensitive cases. Your goal is to obtain necessary details without causing additional distress or leading the interviewee.

Avoid Leading Questions
Leading questions can unintentionally guide the interviewee’s responses, which is particularly problematic in sensitive cases where the circumstances may be complex. Instead of asking, “Did you feel threatened by your coworker’s behavior?” you could ask, “How did your coworker’s behavior affect you?” This open-ended approach allows the interviewee to express their feelings without feeling led to respond in a particular way.

Funnel Technique
The funnel approach involves starting with broad, open-ended questions and gradually narrowing down to more specific questions. This method is particularly useful in sensitive cases because it allows the interviewee to control how much they share initially, building trust as the interview progresses. For instance, you might start with, “Can you walk me through what happened on the day of the incident?” and later ask, “What specific actions made you feel uncomfortable?”

Mindful of Nonverbal Cues
In sensitive interviews, nonverbal communication can reveal more than words. Pay close attention to the interviewee’s body language, facial expressions, and tone of voice. If you notice signs of discomfort, such as crossing arms, avoiding eye contact, or a shaky voice, it may be a cue to slow down, offer reassurance, or revisit your line of questioning.

Managing Emotional Responses

In sensitive cases, emotional responses are common. As an investigator, your role is to manage these responses with care, ensuring that the interview remains productive while providing the interviewee with the support they need.

Pause When Necessary
If an interviewee becomes emotional, it’s important to pause and give them time to collect themselves. This doesn’t mean rushing to comfort them or changing the subject immediately, but rather allowing them space to express their emotions. You might say, “It’s okay to take a moment. We can continue whenever you’re ready.” This approach respects the interviewee’s feelings while maintaining the integrity of the interview.

Normalize Their Feelings
Let the interviewee know that their emotional response is understandable given the circumstances. Statements like, “It’s completely normal to feel upset about what happened,” can help validate their experience and reduce any embarrassment or shame they may feel about expressing their emotions.

Maintain Neutrality
While it’s essential to be supportive, it’s equally important to remain neutral. This means not taking sides, making assumptions, or offering personal opinions. Your neutrality reinforces the interview’s objectivity and fairness, which is necessary for maintaining the investigation’s credibility.

Addressing Trauma with Sensitivity

Trauma-informed interviewing is an approach that recognizes the impact of trauma on an individual’s behavior and responses. This approach requires sensitivity, patience, and a deep understanding of how trauma can affect memory, communication, and emotional regulation.

Use Trauma-Informed Language
When interviewing someone who has experienced trauma, it’s important to use language that avoids triggering or re-traumatizing them. For example, instead of asking, “Why didn’t you report the incident immediately?” you could ask, “Can you share what made it difficult to report the incident at the time?” This shift in language reduces blame and acknowledges the complexity of the trauma response.

Allow for Breaks
Those impacted by trauma may need breaks during the interview to manage their emotional responses. Make it clear at the beginning of the interview that they can request a break at any time. This empowers the interviewee and gives them a sense of control, which is key to supporting those with trauma.

Be Prepared for Memory Gaps
Trauma can affect memory, leading to gaps or inconsistencies in the interviewee’s account. If this happens, avoid pushing for details or expressing frustration. Instead, reassure the interviewee that it’s okay if they don’t remember everything clearly and that you can work with the information they can provide.

Concluding the Interview

The way you conclude an interview in a sensitive case can have lasting effects on the interviewee’s perception of the process and their overall well-being. A thoughtful conclusion provides a sense of closure and clarity about the next steps.

Summarize and Clarify
Before ending the interview, summarize the key points discussed and clarify any remaining questions. This not only helps ensure that you have accurately understood the interviewee’s account but also gives them an opportunity to correct or add information.

Discuss Next Steps
Clearly outline what will happen next in the investigation process. Let the interviewee know when they can expect to hear from you again and what, if any, further involvement they might have. This transparency helps manage any anxiety or uncertainty they may have about the investigation’s outcome.

Offer Resources
If appropriate, provide the interviewee with resources for support, such as counseling services or employee assistance programs. Even if they don’t require these services immediately, knowing they are available can be reassuring.

Conclusion

Interviewing in sensitive cases is one of the most challenging aspects of workplace investigations. It requires a blend of skill and emotional intelligence. By approaching these interviews with care, compassion, and a commitment to fairness, you can gather the necessary information while minimizing harm to the interviewee.

By following these practical tips and adopting a trauma-informed, empathetic approach, you can navigate the complexities of sensitive case interviews with confidence, ultimately leading to more accurate findings and a healthier workplace.

If you liked this article, do me a favor, share it with a colleague or repost it to your network.

Together we’re building a community of investigators committed to elevating workplace culture.

Want access to quick tips for workplace investigations straight to your inbox every monday? Sign up for the newsletter here.